LF6-C.4: a manifestly LOCAL product de-isolation flow realising the GHZ measurement #
Category: 6-Local (the multipartite entangled de-isolation tier; the D1 entangled frontier at the three-party GHZ).
This is LF6-C.4 of specs/lf6-plan.md, the three-party analogue of LF6-A.3
(LocalDeisolationFlow.lean). It exhibits a manifestly local product
de-isolation V_loc = V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2 — each wing an LF5 single-system
(N = 2) de-isolation — and proves it realises the SAME three-qubit
computational-basis measurement as the C.2 flow: its context-fixed pointer-block
Fubini-Study volumes are the GHZ Born weights ghzWeight. So the de-isolation
needs no non-local interaction among the three parties; the GHZ non-locality
lives entirely in the contextual carve (C.1/C.3) and the entangled preparation
(SO-1).
Honest framing (read this; do not get it wrong) #
LF6-C.2's flow is measurementFlow 8 finProdFinEquiv, whose underlying unitary
is the adder σ(j,k) = (j, j+k) on ℤ/8. That N = 8 adder unitary does
NOT factor as (N=2 adder) ⊗ (N=2 adder) ⊗ (N=2 adder), because ℤ/8
(cyclic) is not ℤ/2 × ℤ/2 × ℤ/2 (elementary abelian) — mod-8 addition has
carries. So C.4 is not "prove the C.2 flow factors" (it does not, as a full
unitary).
C.4 instead constructs a manifestly local product de-isolation
V_loc := V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2 (each V_w the LF5 vnDilationV at N = 2, the wing
copy / CNOT in the local axis basis), reindexed onto the joint dilated space, and
proves it realises the same joint measurement (same pointer-block volumes
= ghzWeight). The factorisation is then by construction (V_loc is
defined as a triple tensor product, ghzLocal_factorises); the genuine new
content over A.3 is that the local product dilation is a Naimark dilation of the
joint product POVM at THREE wings (ghzLocal_pullback, composing the three wing
LF5 pullbacks via the Kronecker
(A⊗B⊗C)ᴴ(P⊗Q⊗R)(A⊗B⊗C) = (AᴴPA)⊗(BᴴQB)⊗(CᴴRC) identity, which reuses A.3's
2-wing pullback for the inner two factors) and so reproduces the GHZ diagonal
weights (ghzLocal_pointer_volume, routing through the LF4 POVM-Naimark volume
engine + C.2's nudgedGHZ_born).
So: the N=8-adder C.2 flow is one (non-factoring) unitary completion of the
joint measurement; C.4's product flow is the manifestly-local realisation,
showing the de-isolation CAN be local (three-party product), so the three parties
need never interact.
The construction (clean path, mirroring A.3) #
The local product dilation is a Naimark dilation of the joint computational-basis POVM, with the pullback factorising into per-wing pullbacks:
V_loc := V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2 -- V_w = LF5 vnDilationV @ N=2
(V_loc)ᴴ (Π_i ⊗ Π_j ⊗ Π_k) (V_loc)
= (V_0ᴴ Π_i V_0) ⊗ (V_1ᴴ Π_j V_1) ⊗ (V_2ᴴ Π_k V_2) -- tensor of pullbacks
= |e_i⟩⟨e_i| ⊗ |e_j⟩⟨e_j| ⊗ |e_k⟩⟨e_k| -- each wing: vnDilationV_pullback @ N=2
= |e_{(i,j,k)}⟩⟨e_{(i,j,k)}| -- joint rank-1 projector
The right-associated grouping V_0 ⊗ (V_1 ⊗ V_2) matches C.2's ghzIdx
(Fin 2 × Fin 2 × Fin 2) on the system side and lets the inner V_1 ⊗ V_2
factor reuse A.3's localDeisolation_pullback verbatim.
Honest scope (the C.4 ledger) #
- Exhibited. A genuinely local product de-isolation
V_loc = V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2(ghzLocalV,ghzLocal_factorises—V_locis a triple tensor product), a Naimark dilation of the joint basis POVM (ghzLocal_pullback, the tensor pullback composing the three wing LF5 pullbacks), whose pointer-block FS volumes reproduce the GHZ Born weights (ghzLocal_pointer_volume = ghzWeight); the projectivised product flow is FS-measure-preserving and≠ id(ghzLocalFlow_*). - Imported, not re-derived. Born = FS-volume is derived one layer down (the
moment-map / Duistermaat-Heckman cluster, Gleason-free, no Born put in) and
imported via
povm_born_eq_dilated_volume_uncond; the GHZ state, its Born weightsghzWeight, and the coordinate-Born identitynudgedGHZ_bornare C.2. - Minimal computational-basis carve. As in C.2, the diagonal weights
(1/2, 0, …, 0, 1/2); the Mermin-context carve (whose block correlations carry GHZ's contextuality) is deferred. The contextuality is the C.1 no-go, never in the (local) flow. - Residue: SO-1. The entangled GHZ sector / preparation region is posited, not derived (SO-1: the sector origin, distinct from Paper C Axiom A5). The non-locality lives in the contextual carve and the entangled preparation, never in the (local) flow.
All exports are foundational-triple-only (Gleason-free; the LF4/LF5 POVM-Naimark volume engine is off Busch).
Reference: specs/lf6-plan.md (LF6-C.4).
Boolean-indicator algebra helper #
The reindexing equivs (the system / dilated-space regrouping) #
The joint system reindex is C.2's ghzIdx : Fin 2 × Fin 2 × Fin 2 ≃ Fin 8
(Fin 2 × Fin 2 × Fin 2 right-associated to match the wing column grouping).
The joint dilated-space regrouping
(sys_0 ⊗ ptr_0) ⊗ ((sys_1 ⊗ ptr_1) ⊗ (sys_2 ⊗ ptr_2)) ≃ Fin 8 × Fin 8, sending
((s0,p0),((s1,p1),(s2,p2))) to ((s0,s1,s2), (p0,p1,p2)) (system block, ancilla
block) and reindexing each sys/ptr triple by ghzIdx. This turns the
right-associated product tensor V_0 ⊗ (V_1 ⊗ V_2) into the Naimark form
V : Fin 8 × Fin 8 ← Fin 8.
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
Deliverable 3 (the genuine new content over A.3): the triple tensor pullback #
The local product dilation is a Naimark dilation of the joint product POVM
(the tensor-pullback lemma, LF6-C.4 crux).
(V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2)ᴴ (Π_i ⊗ Π_j ⊗ Π_k) (V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2) = |e_{(i,j,k)}⟩⟨e_{(i,j,k)}|.
The proof genuinely composes the three wing LF5 pullbacks: push the conjugate
transpose across the outer Kronecker (conjTranspose_kronecker), fold the two
Kronecker products into one (← mul_kronecker_mul twice) to expose
(V_0ᴴ Π_i V_0) ⊗ ((V_1 ⊗ V_2)ᴴ (Π_j ⊗ Π_k) (V_1 ⊗ V_2)), discharge the outer
wing by wingDeisolation_pullback (= |e_i⟩⟨e_i|) and the inner two-wing block by
A.3's localDeisolation_pullback (= |e_{(j,k)}⟩⟨e_{(j,k)}|, itself the
composition of the wing-1 and wing-2 pullbacks), and recombine the matrix-unit
Kronecker |e_i⟩⟨e_i| ⊗ |e_{(j,k)}⟩⟨e_{(j,k)}| = |e_{(i,j,k)}⟩⟨e_{(i,j,k)}|
(single_kronecker_single). So all three wing pullbacks are genuinely composed.
Deliverable 2: the local product dilation and its factorisation #
The de-isolation IS a triple tensor product (the locality, by construction).
Stripping the dilated-space / system reindexings recovers exactly the triple
Kronecker product of the three wing de-isolations:
V_loc factorises as V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2. This is the manifest-locality content of
C.4.
The inner two-wing Kronecker de-isolation is an isometry (reused for the triple isometry).
V_loc is an isometry (V_loc)ᴴ V_loc = 1: the triple Kronecker of three
isometries is an isometry (vnDilationV_isom per wing + wingKron2_isom +
one_kronecker_one), transported through the reindex.
The block reshuffle (load-bearing transport lemma). The Naimark ancilla
projector blockProj 8 (ghzIdx (i,j,k)) on Fin 8 × Fin 8 equals the
reindexed triple product of the three wing block projectors
blockProj 2 i ⊗ blockProj 2 j ⊗ blockProj 2 k — the
((s0,p0),((s1,p1),(s2,p2))) ↦ ((s0,s1,s2),(p0,p1,p2)) regrouping made
matrix-level. Three-wing analogue of A.3's blockProj_localReindex.
The Naimark pullback for the local product dilation (in the Naimark
Fin 8 × Fin 8 form): (V_loc)ᴴ Π_c V_loc = |e_c⟩⟨e_c| = ((basisPOVM 8).E c).M.
Transports the triple tensor pullback ghzLocal_pullback through the reshuffle
blockProj_ghzReindex and the reindex (submatrix_mul_equiv,
single_submatrix_symm from A.3).
The local product dilation as a Naimark dilation of the joint
computational-basis POVM basisPOVM 8. The dilation isometry is the manifestly
local V_loc = V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2.
Equations
- CSD.LF6.ghzLocalNaimark = { V := CSD.LF6.ghzLocalV, isom := CSD.LF6.ghzLocal_isom, pullback := CSD.LF6.ghzLocal_naimark_pullback }
Instances For
Operator-level isometry: ‖V_loc ψ‖ = ‖ψ‖.
Deliverable 4: the local product flow reproduces the GHZ diagonal weights #
The reproduction (the C.4 headline). The LOCAL product de-isolation
V_loc = V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2 reproduces the GHZ measurement: its context-fixed
pointer-block w Fubini-Study volume equals the GHZ Born weight ghzWeight w,
for the prepared state φ = nudgedGHZ (the three-qubit GHZ state in the
computational basis, reused from C.2).
The proof routes the local product Naimark dilation ghzLocalNaimark through the
LF4 POVM-Naimark volume machinery povm_born_eq_dilated_volume_uncond
(Born = FS-volume imported from the DH/FS-volume engine, Gleason-free) and reads
the POVM weight via basisPOVM_weight + the GHZ coordinate-Born identity
nudgedGHZ_born. So a manifestly LOCAL three-party flow gives the same
pointer-block volumes as the (non-factoring) N=8-adder C.2 flow.
Deliverable 5: the projectivised local product flow #
The triple product wing-coupling unitary U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2 is a unitary: the
Kronecker of three unitaries (vnUnitary_unitary per wing + one_kronecker_one).
The local product flow unitary U_loc = U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2, reindexed onto
Fin 64: a manifestly local product unitary on the dilated projective space.
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
Basis action of the product unitary U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2: it permutes the
computational basis by vnPerm 2 on each wing. Reuses A.3's two-wing
vnUnitaryKron_mulVec_single for the inner factor.
The flow unitary's Euclidean basis action.
The local product de-isolation flow Φ_loc = (U_loc • ·) on the dilated
projective ontic space ℂℙ^{63} = ℙ(EuclideanSpace ℂ (Fin 64)). Manifestly local
(U_loc = U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2).
Equations
Instances For
The local product flow is Fubini-Study measure-preserving (the Liouville /
hΦ_pres content) — directly from fubiniStudyMeasure_smul_invariant for the
product unitary U_loc.
Basis-ray action of the local product flow: it moves the ray at
ghzFlowEquiv (z0, z1, z2) to the one at
ghzFlowEquiv (vnPerm 2 z0, vnPerm 2 z1, vnPerm 2 z2).
The local product flow is genuinely not the identity (Φ_loc ≠ id): the
basis ray at ghzFlowEquiv ((1,0),(1,0),(1,0)) (every wing: system 1, ground
apparatus) moves to the distinct ray at ghzFlowEquiv ((1,1),(1,1),(1,1)) — the
product coupling correlates each apparatus with its system.
Deliverable 6 (the flow ↔ dilation tie): the local flow realises the dilation #
The three-party analogue of A.3's localDeisolationFlow_realises_localNaimark: at
the projective level, the LOCAL product flow carries the embedded ray
[ψ ⊗ (a₀ ⊗ a₀ ⊗ a₀)] exactly to the dilated ray [V_loc ψ]. The tie is genuine
and routine: V_loc = U_loc ∘ (· ⊗ ground) because each wing is
vnDilationV 2 = vnUnitary 2 * embedGround 2, so the triple product dilation
factors through the product flow U_loc = U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2.
The local product ground-state embedding ψ ↦ ψ ⊗ (a₀ ⊗ a₀ ⊗ a₀),
reindexed onto the dilated space Fin 8 × Fin 8 ← Fin 8 exactly as ghzLocalV. It
is the triple Kronecker product of the three identical wing ground embeddings
embedGround 2, so ghzLocalV = U_loc ∘ embed (ghzLocalV_eq).
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
The inner two-wing ground embedding is an isometry.
The ground embedding is an isometry embedᴴ embed = 1: the triple Kronecker
of three embedGround 2 isometries, transported through the reindex.
The local product flow unitary as a matrix on Fin 8 × Fin 8 (the dilated
space before the final finProdFinEquiv reindex onto Fin 64). It is the triple
Kronecker U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2 reindexed by ghzDilEquiv; reindex finProdFinEquiv ·
recovers ghzLocalFlowUnitary.val (ghzLocalFlowReindexed_reindex).
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
The dilation factors through the flow (matrix level): V_loc = U_loc ∘ embed.
Genuine content: each wing vnDilationV 2 is vnUnitary 2 * embedGround 2, so
the triple Kronecker V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2 splits as (U_0 ⊗ U_1 ⊗ U_2) * (embed_0 ⊗ embed_1 ⊗ embed_2) (mul_kronecker_mul twice); the shared dilated
middle index is folded by submatrix_mul_equiv.
The flow-matrix reindex coherence: pushing ghzLocalFlowReindexed along the
final finProdFinEquiv recovers the flow unitary ghzLocalFlowUnitary.val.
The embedded vector of a nonzero preparation is nonzero (embed is isometric).
The post-flow vector of a nonzero preparation is nonzero (V_loc is isometric).
The reindexed embedded ray representative is nonzero (piLpCongrLeft isometry).
The reindexed post-flow ray representative is nonzero.
The flow ↔ dilation operator identity: V_loc ψ (reindexed onto Fin 64)
equals the flow unitary U_loc applied to the embedded vector
ψ ⊗ (a₀ ⊗ a₀ ⊗ a₀) (reindexed). Composes the matrix factorisation ghzLocalV_eq,
the toEuclideanLin-of-product split, the reindex naturality
toEuclideanLin_reindex_piLpCongrLeft, and ghzLocalFlowReindexed_reindex.
The LOCAL flow realises the local Naimark dilation (the C.4 flow ↔ dilation
tie). At the projective level, the local product de-isolation flow Φ_loc
carries the embedded ray [ψ ⊗ (a₀ ⊗ a₀ ⊗ a₀)] exactly to the dilated ray
[V_loc ψ], for every nonzero preparation ψ : EuclideanSpace ℂ (Fin 8). So the
local Naimark dilation ghzLocalNaimark consumed by the volume engine is
dynamically realised by the manifestly local flow.
Deliverable 7: the capstone #
The LF6-C.4 capstone: a manifestly LOCAL product de-isolation realises the GHZ measurement. Conjuncts:
- the de-isolation IS a triple tensor product
V_loc = V_0 ⊗ V_1 ⊗ V_2(ghzLocal_factorises) — manifest three-party locality, by construction; - it is a Naimark dilation of the joint product POVM: the tensor pullback
(V_0⊗V_1⊗V_2)ᴴ (Π_i ⊗ Π_j ⊗ Π_k) (V_0⊗V_1⊗V_2) = |e_{(i,j,k)}⟩⟨e_{(i,j,k)}|(ghzLocal_pullback), composing the three wing LF5 pullbacks; - the LOCAL product flow reproduces the GHZ diagonal weights: pointer-block FS
volume
= ghzWeightevery outcome (ghzLocal_pointer_volume); - the projectivised product flow is FS-measure-preserving
(
ghzLocalFlow_measurePreserving); - and genuinely
≠ id(ghzLocalFlow_ne_id); - the LOCAL flow realises the local Naimark dilation:
Φ_loc [ψ ⊗ (a₀ ⊗ a₀ ⊗ a₀)] = [V_loc ψ]for every nonzero preparation (ghzLocalFlow_realises_localNaimark) — the flow ↔ dilation tie, so the dilation whose carve givesghzWeight(conjunct 3) is dynamically realised by the manifestly local flow.
So the de-isolation needs NO non-local interaction among the three parties; the
GHZ non-locality is entirely in the contextual carve (C.1/C.3) and the entangled
preparation (SO-1). The N=8-adder C.2 flow is a non-factoring unitary completion
of the same measurement (ℤ/8 ≠ ℤ/2 × ℤ/2 × ℤ/2); C.4's product flow is the
manifestly-local one. Born = FS-volume is imported (LF5/DH/POVM-Naimark engine),
not re-derived. Residue: SO-1 (the entangled GHZ sector posited). Honest ledger:
module docstring.